Home  /  Toy Safety Standards  /  ASTM F963 Versions

ASTM F963-11 vs F963-16: Which Version Applies to Your Toy?

Neither — ASTM F963-23 has been mandatory since April 2024, and reports citing F963-16 or F963-17 are no longer accepted by the CPSC. Here is the version timeline, what changed, and the pigment, coating and heavy-metal limits you must lock down before tooling — not after a failed lab test.

The short answer: ASTM F963-23 is the current mandatory US toy safety standard, effective 20 April 2024 under 16 CFR Part 1250. Test reports and Children's Product Certificates (CPC) based on F963-17 are no longer accepted by the CPSC after that date. If you are placing an order now, the lab report must cite F963-23.

The ASTM F963 version timeline

Buyers often search for "F963-11 vs F963-16" because those are the versions printed on older quotes. Both are long superseded. The table below is the sequence that matters when you check a supplier's paperwork.

Version Status Mandatory from What it means for a buyer today
F963-11 Superseded 12 June 2012 First version incorporated as mandatory after CPSIA; replaced F963-08. Reports citing it are obsolete.
F963-16 Superseded 30 April 2017 Published October 2016. Common on quotes from 2017–2018, but no longer acceptable for a new CPC.
F963-17 Superseded 28 February 2018 Adopted by CPSC direct final rule (4 Dec 2017). Reports based on it stopped being accepted on 20 April 2024 — this is the one that still catches buyers out.
F963-23 · CURRENT Mandatory 20 April 2024 Published 13 Oct 2023, incorporated by CPSC direct final rule (18 Jan 2024). The only version a new US test report and CPC should cite.

A practical rule: when a factory hands you a test report, look at the standard version on the first page, not just the word "pass". A passing F963-17 report is not a passing US compliance file in 2026.

What actually changed in F963-23

The 2023 revision is not a paperwork update. Six changes affect how a plush, vinyl, ABS or resin toy is designed and specced:

  • Heavy elements in substrates. Exemptions for paper, textiles and modelling clay are described separately and more strictly. A fabric covering is no longer an automatic exemption for the substrate underneath — relevant for plush with plastic eyes, noses and internal parts.
  • Phthalates widened from 6 to 8. Now aligned with 16 CFR Part 1307: DEHP, DBP, BBP, DINP, DIBP, DPENP, DHEXP and DCHP, each below 0.1%, for all children's toys. Previously DEHP at 3% was limited to pacifiers and rattles.
  • Battery accessibility. Higher requirements for battery compartments (a tool or two independent movements to open), new abuse tests for lithium-ion cells, and associated instruction and warning labels.
  • Magnetic toys. A 24-hour flux decay test in addition to the 50 kG²/mm² flux index, plus a stricter accessibility probe — catches magnets that pass once then degrade.
  • Sound and expanding materials. Close-to-the-ear peak limits and new impulse-noise limits; expanded scope for water-absorbing expanding materials.
  • Traceability labelling and projectile toys. New sourcing-label requirements and re-sequenced projectile clauses with kinetic energy limits.

Toy pigments, coatings & heavy-element limits

This is where most custom-toy failures originate. Painted eyes, printed fabric, soft PVC parts and coloured resin all carry pigments and film-forming solids that are tested as a dry coating. Section 4.3.5 of ASTM F963 sets these maximum soluble migrated element limits (ppm, mg/kg):

ElementSolubility limitWhere it typically shows up
Antimony (Sb)60 ppmPigments, flame retardants in textiles
Arsenic (As)25 ppmContaminated mineral pigments
Barium (Ba)1000 ppmFillers, printed plush fabric, granular stuffing
Cadmium (Cd)75 ppmBright yellow/red pigments, stabilised PVC
Chromium (Cr)60 ppmChrome-based colourants, metal plating
Lead (Pb)90 ppmPaint, ink, pigments, soldered or plated parts
Mercury (Hg)60 ppmContaminated raw pigment batches
Selenium (Se)500 ppmCadmium-selenide red/orange pigments

On top of the soluble-element table, two total lead ceilings apply: 90 ppm in surface coatings (16 CFR 1303) and 100 ppm in accessible substrates (CPSIA). These are separate tests — a pigment can pass one and fail the other.

For the EU the equivalent is EN71-3, which covers 19 elements with a different sample preparation and different limits. The two reports are not interchangeable. A toy sold into both markets needs both, which is why we spec materials to the stricter of the two from the first sketch.

A compliance checklist you can send your factory

Copy this into your RFQ before tooling starts. Each item is cheaper to fix on paper than after a mould is cut.

  1. Confirm the destination market and require the lab report to cite ASTM F963-23 (US) or the current EN71 series (EU/UK), as applicable.
  2. Ask the pigment / masterbatch / ink supplier for a heavy-metal test report covering all eight soluble elements, plus total lead for both coating and substrate.
  3. Require phthalate-free (8P, each <0.1%) declarations for every plasticised PVC, soft vinyl and flexible component.
  4. Specify eye and nose attachment by pull/torque test method, not by glue type — small-part failure is still the top recall cause.
  5. If the toy has batteries, magnets or sound modules, flag them at design stage; all three gained new tests in F963-23.
  6. Book the CPSC-accepted lab slot when the golden sample ships, not after it passes internally.
  7. Have the importer issue the CPC from that report; keep reports and certificates on file for at least five years.

This page is a plain-language buyer guide, not legal advice. Standards and CPSC rulemaking change; always confirm the current mandatory version and your importer's documentation requirements with a CPSC-accepted laboratory before production.

Design it to pass the first time.

Tell us your market, material and colour way. We will map the required tests, spec pigments and attachments to F963-23 / EN71, and build the sample so the lab report comes back clean.

Get a free compliance spec review

ASTM F963 questions we get most

Which ASTM F963 version is mandatory for US toys now?

ASTM F963-23, effective 20 April 2024 under 16 CFR Part 1250. It replaced F963-17; reports and CPCs based on F963-17 are no longer accepted by the CPSC after that date.

Is an F963-16 or F963-11 test report still valid?

No. F963-11 became mandatory in June 2012, then F963-16 (2017), F963-17 (2018) and F963-23 (2024). Any earlier report should be re-issued against F963-23 by a CPSC-accepted lab.

What are the heavy-element limits for toy pigments and coatings?

Soluble limits: Sb 60, As 25, Ba 1000, Cd 75, Cr 60, Pb 90, Hg 60 and Se 500 ppm. Separately, total lead is capped at 90 ppm in coatings and 100 ppm in substrates.

Can an EN71-3 report substitute for ASTM F963 testing?

No. EN71-3 covers 19 elements under a different scheme. Dual-market toys need both reports; we build to the stricter of the two so one production run clears both.

Which phthalates are restricted under F963-23?

Eight (DEHP, DBP, BBP, DINP, DIBP, DPENP, DHEXP, DCHP), each below 0.1%, aligned with 16 CFR Part 1307. Plasticised PVC and soft vinyl parts are the usual failure points.

Who issues the CPC?

The manufacturer or importer issues it, based on a test report from a CPSC-accepted third-party lab testing against the current mandatory version of ASTM F963 plus applicable CPSIA requirements.

Start your project

Get a free compliance spec review

Tell us your target market, material and colours. We'll map the required F963-23 / EN71 tests, flag pigment and attachment risks, and tell you what it costs before you tool.

Chat on WhatsApp

We reply within 24 hours. No mailing list, no follow-up sequence — just a straight answer on feasibility, MOQ and cost.

Customize

See your toy — and its price — before you commit.

Pick a material, size, and color to visualize your custom toy concept. Ready? Get an instant quote.

Get a Quote